A chance to hear the latest on employment, property, corporate and restructuring and insolvency and to ask questions and share your opinions.
DATE: Thursday 7 May 2020, 10:00am - 11:00am- delivered via Zoom Video Conference
Search site
Contact our office
Make an enquiry
Ms Rogerson (“Ms R”) lived in a Council property owned by Bolsover District Council. Ms R was the tenant and Bolsover Council the landlord.
In September 2013, Ms R was mowing her front garden when she stepped backwards onto a manhole cover. The cover gave way and she fell into the void beneath, seriously injuring herself. The manhole cover itself and the area below was the property of Severn Trent.
Bolsover Council had a duty to maintain the structure and exterior of the property. The question was, did the landlord also have a duty of care under the Defective Premises Act 1972 (“the Act”)? Was the landlord liable for the injury caused as a result of the defective inspection cover? After all, the cover was owned by Severn Trent.
The Act says that a landlord owes a duty of care to anyone who might be affected by defects in the state of premises let by the landlord.
In the Court’s view, the manhole cover was an ‘obvious risk’, given that it was located in the garden of domestic premises. It was irrelevant that it was actually the property of Severn Trent as the cover, in the Court’s opinion, fell within the definition of ‘structure and exterior’ of the property. Bolsover Council had undertaken an inspection of the property in May 2013 but there was insufficient evidence to show that the covers had been inspected or any risk identified.
The Act does not actually impose a duty on landlords to inspect a tenanted property. However, a landlord is required to take such care as is reasonable to ensure occupiers are reasonably safe. The Judge found that the defect in this case would have been discovered had an inspector applied some lateral pressure on the cover. Effectively, it was a defect which the landlord could have discovered and should have known about had it exercised reasonable care.
The landlord was therefore held liable for the personal injury, loss and damage claimed by Ms R.
This case seems to widen the scope for claims under the Act and landlords should take note. Whilst this case confirms that landlords are not technically under a duty to implement a system of regular inspection, it is certainly advisable. This is especially so when there is a “clear and obvious danger” or the occupants may be vulnerable. The key consideration is: what would a competent landlord exercising reasonable care do?
In terms of inspections generally, a basic visual check may not always be enough to discharge the duty of care. An inspection should be full and thorough. This will depend on how apparent or foreseeable a defect may be, the nature of the risk, safety regulations, and what work might be involved. To ensure an inspection is truly thorough, detailed notes should be taken and a risk assessment considered. Issues should be remedied, monitored and referred, where necessary.
If you wish to discuss any of the issues raised in this blog, please contact Victoria Raven at vlr@hughes-paddison.co.uk
A chance to hear the latest on employment, property, corporate and restructuring and insolvency and to ask questions and share your opinions.
DATE: Thursday 7 May 2020, 10:00am - 11:00am- delivered via Zoom Video Conference
Cheltenham based solicitors, Hughes Paddison, have announced two promotions within their Senior Management Team. Jon Rathbone has been made an Equity Director within the firm, whilst Julie Bennett has been made a Director.
What our clients say
“Hughes Paddison have provided assistance on numerous occasions consistently acting in an exemplary fashion whilst dealing with all aspects of the issue at hand. It is extremely reassuring to know that our company is represented by such a competent and professional firm.”– Commercial Director, Ferroli Limited
“We are lucky to have the services of Paul Engelbrecht on hand. He has always met our requests and ridiculous deadlines and puts himself out to make life easier for us”– Company Secretary - Supergroup PLC
“Paul has repeatedly demonstrated a high level of legal skill, accuracy, attentiveness and most of all, commercial acumen. I particularly appreciate his eye for detail and ability to take complex legal issues and explain them in lay terms. ”– Relationship Director RBS
“Whilst constantly demonstrating his consummate professionalism and occasional wry sense of humour David has at all times supported me and acted in my best interests resulting in a successful financial settlement and my divorce.”– V
“Jennifer provided sound professional legal advice which I needed to help me to sort out the legal and financial aspects of a difficult personal situation. I wouldn't hesitate to go to her with any family legal matters I have in future.”– R
“Having the support of Marcus throughout what has been a very painful divorce has really helped me get through the last 18 months. Although this has personally been a very difficult process, I know that Marcus has done everything possible to make it as smooth as it can be. I really appreciate the honest, open feedback to all of my questions and also how quickly he responded to them. Above all else, Marcus really does seem to care about his clients and their families. I never had the feeling that this was just a job for Marcus, and Im so grateful that I was fortunate enough to have had Marcus recommended to me when I did.”– R
Clicking the Accept All button means you are accepting analytics and third-party cookies (check the full list). We use cookies to optimise site functionality and give you the best possible experience. To control which cookies are set, click Settings.
Our use of cookies.
You can learn more detailed information in our Privacy Policy
Some cookies are essential, whilst others help us improve your experience by providing insights into how the site is being used. The technology to maintain this privacy management relies on cookie identifiers. Removing or resetting your browser cookies will reset these preferences.
Essential Cookies
These cookies enable core website functionality, and can only be disabled by changing your browser preferences.
Google Analytics cookies help us to understand your experience of the website and do not store any personal data. Click here for a full list of Google Analytics cookies used on this site.
Third-Party cookies are set by our partners and help us to improve your experience of the website. Click here for a full list of third-party plugins used on this site.
Comments